Decision #1: Where to get married.
We finally agreed on Milwaukee, Wisconsin, which is my hometown. Weather there can be tricky, and we definitely don’t want to worry about winter travel delays, so spring was the goal. Back in June, we took a weekend trip to visit venues. Since I like to have a LOT of information before making a decision, we visited a LOT of places. And since I’m a listmaker, I had a schedule in excel with arrival and departure times for each place, contact names, addresses, phone numbers, etc. I also made a binder with all the pricing or online info I had gathered so far – it was a lot of prep work, but it helped keep everything straight. The weekend was super busy, but it was a fun way to see the city!
We also agreed on brunch (our favorite meal of the day/week!) and 100-150 people, so that colors my opinions also.
So here’s how it went (all photos are my own, probably taken by future husband):
1. Villa Terrace – since the first time I visited this art museum with family years ago, I thought it would be the perfect wedding venue. It’s a gorgeous Mediterranean Villa on top of a hill with a view of Lake Michigan and a huge lawn & gardens below.
Pros: Pictures will be gorgeous; it’s a very unique venue; plenty of rooms available for getting ready, signing the license, etc; the Charles Allis, their sister museum, can host larger receptions (I still like the Villa better)
Cons: I liked the idea of having the wedding in the garden, but it requires a very expensive tent rental and therefore is very rare; the indoor reception area fits 80 max, so this would be for the ceremony only; no dancing allowed inside (not an issue for us); rental was somewhat expensive for ceremony-only
2. Boerner Botanical Gardens – as the name suggests, this is basically an outdoor museum of gardens. We looked at an outdoor area for the ceremony and Boerner Hall for the reception.
Pros: we could provide guests with tickets to tour the gardens after brunch (great perk since our reception will be over mid-afternoon and it’s nice to have options for the out-of-town guests); beautiful gardens for pictures; full-service kitchen in the building; free parking; enthusiastic coordinator
Cons: the hall looked like a standard hotel ballroom and we were hoping for something different; my family has attended Sunday brunch here and wasn’t impressed with the food; lots of little charges for chairs, linens, bartenders, cake cutting, etc.
3. Hyatt Regency – cool downtown hotel I always remembered for the glass elevators and spinning restaurant at the top.
Pros: THE BEST venue coordinator we met all weekend! Misty was super knowledgeable about the industry, very honest and helpful. The staff will do pretty much everything for you in terms of set-up and tear down, working with vendors, helping to take gifts to a hotel room, etc – it sounded like it would be very low-maintenance and stress-free. Polaris is no longer a full-time restaurant, but can be used for private parties such as our cocktail hour.
Cons: the rooms are standard hotel ballrooms with strange patterned carpet like you always see in hotels, and since future husband travels a lot for work and lives out of hotels at times, another hotel ballroom wasn’t his style
4. Iron Horse Hotel – this is one of the newest hotels in Milwaukee and I’ve read that it is a very cool boutique hotel. We looked at the Gallery space. I asked about the outdoor space too, maybe for the rehearsal or ceremony, but the Upper Yard can only fit about 50-75 people, and the lower Yard is open to the public after 11am.
Pros: Very cool lobby and fun rooms; close to the Harley-Davidson museum for visitors
Cons: Gallery is in the basement, and mom’s first reaction was, “It smells like a basement!”; I also thought it was set up strangely – there are large poles that might block views during a ceremony or reception toast, and it felt really dark; rooms are expensive
40.714269
-74.005973